Tuesday 24 May 2011

Where now for Scottish Labour?

There is no doubting that the Holyrood election was a significant moment in Scottish history, a day when the last lingering doubts that the SNP are a fringe party and Scotland is a Labour country were put to bed.  Well actually it was more the case that they were taken out the back and unceremoniously shot, such was the devastation inflicted upon Labour by the Nats.  Sure we can try to pretend that it was all the Lib Dems’ fault for selling out and then voting for the SNP, but ultimately it was the rejection of an inane, inappropriate and ineffective campaign by the wider electorate.

The Scottish Labour campaign failed on every level.  A focus on the Conservatives was utterly out of tune with the growing understanding amongst voters that elections to Holyrood and Westminster are completely different beasts (a mistake, interestingly, that the SNP made last year).  There was an over the top attempt to out-promise the SNP on spending pledges, regardless of the looming spectre of savage cuts to the Scottish budget.  And the few policies which didn’t seem to be identical to those in the Nationalist manifesto, such as the pseudo-macho posturing on knife crime, were ill thought out and turn offs to those choosing where to cast their vote.

Ultimately, it was a monumental failure by a supposedly professional political party.  We demonstrated that we had learnt nothing from 2007; that we had failed to adapt to the Scottish political environment as it now exists; and that our presumption that we would simply be handed back power by a grateful electorate following the brief flirtation with the Nats was woefully misplaced.

Personalities definitely played their part in the debacle, with Iain Gray horrendously mismatched against the big beast of Alex Salmond.  It ironically didn’t need to be that way – Salmond’s greatest strengths (humour, confidence, vision) are also his biggest weaknesses (smugness, arrogance, undeliverable promises) and the voters could easily punish him for that if they didn’t believe he was the best man for the job (and regardless of the actual fact that voters do not directly choose the FM, the election definitely had this as a motivation).  But Scotland did believe that he was the best First Minister available, with polling consistently showing that Labour voters thought Salmond would do a better job than Gray.

However, more so than personalities, I feel that the hammering meted out at this election boiled down to two key facts – the misnomer of Scottish Labour and the geographical exclusivity that the party has allowed itself to become restricted to.

We talk of Scottish Labour and yet, in reality, there is no such thing.  As the party who prides ourselves on having delivered devolution, we have demonstrably failed to devolve our own party structures, leaving the SNP free to use the term ‘London Labour’ with such great success that our own MSPs now apply it.  Iain Gray was not my leader as an ordinary member of the Labour Party, his leadership extremely limited to the pool of MSPs.  Not the councillors across the country, not the MPs either when they were in Government or in Opposition, not the MEPs and not the membership, the supposed pool of future representatives.  This is a very important point, explored by Ross Martin and others.  I know that colleagues are wary of devolving Scottish Labour too far, of creating a body which conflicts with the UK wide party, but we are already past this stage.  For example, Labour at Holyrood firmly opposed the minimum pricing legislation of the minority SNP administration at the same time as Labour at Westminster was considering it.  The very reason we have devolution is as recognition that there are legislative, cultural and historical differences between Scotland and England which require different approaches.  If the country requires different approaches from its legislative bodies, then it definitely requires different approaches from its political parties.

The next Leader of the Scottish Labour Party should indeed be the leader of all Scottish Labour.  He or she should be seen as having the ability to take the party forward in Scotland, working closely with our colleagues in Westminster, local government and the European Parliament as a coherent but distinct team.  Councillors do not look to Westminster to drive their decisions, and our MEPs are actually members of a separate political grouping which sets its own agenda, yet we have retained an impression that our MSPs are to remain subservient to Westminster.  This does not benefit us in either context, and effectively concedes the debate to the SNP, allowing them to dismiss the party as uninterested and uncommitted to Scotland.

We are not alone in finding this a struggle – the Scottish Lib Dems had the impossible task of trying to explain that as a federal party they were not directly supportive of the Coalition Government at Westminster, whilst the Scottish Conservatives have long struggled with the fact that they are, well, Conservatives, with all the history and connotation that that brings.  However, our responsibility is to find a new approach for Scottish Labour, to create a party which remains connected to the broader UK movement but which can also demonstrate our relevance to the electorate in Scotland.  This requires distinctive policy and an ambition to use the Scottish Parliament as a vehicle for reshaping Scotland.  The SNP propose big visions of changing the country – we can argue that the vision is not correct or indeed deliverable, however it is still a vision.  It is not simple management of the status quo, but rather a belief that Scotland can achieve great things.  This motivates and inspires, particularly at a time of challenge and particularly in contrast to a negative campaign of “Vote SNP, get Armageddon”.  A positive, ambitious vision for Scotland should be the fundamental drive of Scottish Labour – if we are not dreamers then we are nothing as a political party.  The Scottish Parliament offers us opportunities for the kind of policy which is far harder to achieve at Westminster, particularly given the political arithmetic of the first past the post system, however we are not successful in explaining to voters that we understand the opportunity, and responsibility, of this resource.  We have the opportunity to be proudly Scottish, British, European and Internationalist, and should trust in the positive appeal of that message.

Tying into this challenge is the geographical exclusivity of the Labour Party in Scotland, which was shown to be a fatal flaw at this year’s election.  We talk proudly, and complacently, of our heartlands in the Central Belt and Western Scotland, the areas in which it is claimed, previously with a degree of truth, that you could stand a monkey in a red rosette and they would win.  Part of the reason that these areas are heartlands is due to their contrast with the rest of Scotland.  The Labour Party is virtually a fringe party across the expanse of the Highlands and Islands, the North East and the Borders.  We are seen as out of touch and irrelevant to rural communities, to the farming and fishing industries, to the non-Glasgow populace in Scotland.  We lack the traditional support of the Lib Dems and Conservatives amongst these constituencies and the ability of the SNP to be a very broad church, the drive of independence bringing together disparate political stances.  Furthermore, our safety in the industrial belt left us not needing to reach out to these areas, particularly in an electoral environment which was believed to make majority government virtually impossible.

2011 turned out to be the perfect storm, as the SNP made massive inroads into the Central Belt heartlands at the same time as the Lib Dem vote vanished into the abyss.  We lacked any sort of ability to mount a challenge for the falling Lib Dem seats, and would have lost the overwhelming majority of them in a ‘good’ election.  Every Lib Dem seat which they lost turned to the SNP, an instant gain for the Nats of monumental proportions.  This was further heightened by the sheer scale of their vote in the NE and other areas, where they managed to take MSPs off the list as well as in the constituencies.

At the same time they cut a bloody swathe through ‘safe’ Labour seats, removing MSPs in a raft without Labour being able to replace them elsewhere.  Every city in Scotland is now predominantly, if not wholly, SNP reflecting their success in appealing to the electorate in its widest sense.  As we had seen at previous elections, Labour’s geographic exclusivity left the party with nowhere to go when the SNP made inroads, with no fall back seats to challenge the SNP in or to gain from the other parties.  The conditions were all in place for this defeat, we just failed to address them at any stage of the process.

It is an overused cliché for political parties in the UK to look to the US for answers, however there is something that Scottish Labour should learn from – the Democratic Party’s 50 State Campaign.  This shift in approach, led by Howard Dean, moved the Democrats’ focus from simply their safe blue states of the East and West Coasts, to finding ways to connect with the forgotten voters in the Republican red states of the South and Centre.  This was a challenge and a controversial step, with some of the elite of the party worrying about the impact on policy of listening to the electorate of those states, however it also brought great success at every level of politics in the US.

Scottish Labour needs to devolve its structure and to develop a 50 State approach for Scotland, one which shows that we have relevance to the voter in Sutherland or Aberdeenshire as much as we do to those in Springburn or Dumbarton.  We need to discover a new generation of Scottish Labour representatives, those working and living with the reality of a devolved Scotland, who see Holyrood as a key means by which to change Scotland.  The beauty of the Labour movement is, and always should be, that we appeal to a broad spectrum of the electorate, particularly in Scotland.  I think that the frequent descriptions of Scotland as a centre-left country oversimplify the situation dramatically, ignoring the strong traditional small ‘c’ conservative tradition in Scotland, however it is true that the political, cultural and electoral environment offer opportunities which are hard to achieve at Westminster.  We should not simply be the party of the working class communities of the urban conurbations, who in any case are starting to reject the expectation that we are their only choice.  We should also be the party which represents our rural communities as they struggle with the challenges of employment and population dispersal; of our aspirational communities looking to harness the power of Scotland’s education system and traditional entrepreneurial spirit to break free from poverty; of ethnic minority communities as they contribute to developing new ideas of Scottishness, broad and beautiful in their multifaceted nature.

Regaining success in Scotland cannot simply be a case of winning back the Glasgow seats, Clydebank, Airdrie and other seats we consider rightfully ‘ours’, of merely patching over the cracks and waiting for the inevitable drift of voters back to their true home with us.  If we wait for that to happen, we will be finished as a party, our credibility and commitment washed away in arrogance and complacency.  We have to create a party which matters, which is optimistic yet realistic, which believes Scotland can be a better place and that we possess the abilities and resources to do so.  I believe we need to be a party which is willing to challenge the consensus, to question the unquestioned truths of how Scotland functions as a society, and yet which is willing to work with other parties for the common good, to demonstrate that our first priority is the progress of Scotland and the people we represent.

We ironically have a unique opportunity to do that now.  Our body of MSPs has been wiped out, leaving space for new candidates and ideas to put themselves forward.  The review which is taking place, alongside the election of a new Leader, is welcome but we have to ensure that we do not fall into the trap of believing that the status quo is good enough.  We have to change and we have to reconnect with the electorate – we ignored the signs in 2007 and have been punished for it.  2011 was not just a blip, it was the third national election (Holyrood 2007 and 2011 and the European Parliamentary elections in 2009) that we have lost out of four, with the UK General Election being our only success.  The pattern is now for the SNP to win – they out finance, out resource, out campaign and out think us.  We are no longer the favourites, the big players of Scottish politics – in Glasgow we face the reality that by next year we could be in opposition at every level of government.  We are now the underdogs, and we need to start fighting back with that mindset.

Scottish politics has changed forever – it is now time for the Scottish Labour Party to catch up.

988 comments:

1 – 200 of 988   Newer›   Newest»
Mr.Ketupat said...

Slotboss

Mr.Ketupat said...

login Slotboss

Mr.Ketupat said...

daftar Slotboss

Mr.Ketupat said...

link Slotboss

akubelibukuditiara said...

login slotboss

Mr.Ketupat said...

alternatif Slotboss

Mr.Ketupat said...

link alternatif Slotboss

akubelibukuditiara said...

daftar slotboss

akubelibukuditiara said...

link alternatif slotboss

Mr.Ketupat said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

tes halo i love you

Mr.Ketupat said...

Zaman sekarang memang asik bermain game tapi tauhkah kamu ada dampak buruk bagi kesehatan kamu jika bermain game setiap hari

Mr.Ketupat said...

Terlalu asik Bermain game ketahuilah rambut rusak jika tidak permah dirawat terlalu asik bermain game

Mr.Ketupat said...

Tumbuhan kini bisa menjadi alternatif obat hebal tumbuhan yang bisa dimanfaatkan untuk kesehatan rambut

Aku kan Ikan said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Mr.Ketupat said...

Bicara soal kebudayaan pastinya beragam dong salah satunya cina nih ada refresnsi silahkan mampir ya " Kebudayaan Cina Kuno yang Bisa Diterapkan Hingga Zaman Kini "

Mr.Ketupat said...

Disekolah atau kampus suka banyak ada kegiatan sosial tapi bagaimana di masyarkat? ini aku ada informasi silahkan mampir " Kegiatan Sosial? Anda Aktif Kegiatan Sosial Dimasyarakat "

Mr.Ketupat said...

Cerita anak rantau ada yang sedih dan ada yang seru tetapi dibalik cerita itu anak rantau bekerja keras untuk dapat bertahan hidup atau mencari nafkah ini aku ada informasi seputaran anak rantau silahkan mampir " Kesulitan Anak Rantau Jauh Dengan Keluarga "

Mr.Ketupat said...

Mau tau cara untuk mengetahui sifat si doi disini nih mampir ke artikel aku cara membaca pikiran orang

Savage said...

mau semakin pintar? ayo belajar cara membaca pikiran orang

Mr.Ketupat said...

Sering bertengkar dengan pacar ini tips cara membaca pikiran orang

Aku kan Ikan said...

pasti kalian bingung tingkah laku pacar kalian kan, aku baca artikel ini cara membaca pikiran orang, jadi paham aku

Savage said...

sedang mengandung kehamilan pertama? nih ada referensi hamil trimester pertama

Aku kan Ikan said...

Banyak Perubahan? Jangan Bingung, ini dia hal-hal yang harus di perhatikan saat kehamilan pada hamil trimester pertama

Savage said...

suka berlompat dan memanjat? ini dia olahraga yang cocok buat kamu olahraga parkour

Savage said...

penggemar bola? bahkan ingin tau sejarahnya? nih ada referensi asal-usul sepak bola

BOBOIBOY said...

PUNYA KUCING PERSIA? ATAU PENGEN PUNYA KUCING PERSIA? YUK PELAJARI TENTANG KUCING PERSIA DI KUCING PERSIA

Mr.Ketupat said...

Jaga Kesehatan mata kalian 6 Tips Cara Menjaga Kesehatan Mata

Mr.Ketupat said...

Ketahuilah anak memiliki 5 Dunia Game yang Dimainkan Anak Usia 5-10 Tahun

Aku kan Ikan said...

Sering Minum Teh Poci? tau ngk sih ada sejarahnya ternyata !!!

Aku kan Ikan said...

Sering sakit punggung saat hamil muda, Normal atau Tidak?

Savage said...

suka terapi? nih manfaat terapi ikan

Savage said...

pelihara kucing? kenali tanda dan ciri ciri kucing rabies

Savage said...

pelihara anjing? kenali tanda dan ciri ciri anjing rabies

Savage said...

stop merokok! ini dia bahaya merokok bagi kesehatan

Aku kan Ikan said...

Penting nya menjaga kesehatan fisik, dan juga kesehatan mental, ini ada tips menjaga kesehatan mental saat pandemi yang cocok untuk kita

Aku kan Ikan said...

Bingung ruang warna itu apa? Ruang warna dan pengaruh foto yaitu...

Aku kan Ikan said...

Mau tau dimana dan apa aja diy yang bisa dijual?

BOBOIBOY said...

Hari raya imlek? yuk ketahui tentang hari raya imlek di imlek 2022

BOBOIBOY said...

Usia tua tidak menghalangi kita untuk beraktivitas, yuk pelajari tenang olahraga untuk lansia di lansia

BOBOIBOY said...

Liburan jauh tapi keberatan sama barang bawaan? yuk belajar packing atau berkemas barang di Packing barang

BOBOIBOY said...

Pengen pake skincare, tapi bingung milih yang mana? yuk pelajari tentang skincare di Skincare terbaik

Mr.Ketupat said...

Bantu Baca Artikrl 5 Cara Untuk Membuat Ice Teh Indonesia

Mr.Ketupat said...

Bantu Baca Artikrl 5 Kata Kata Anak Rantau Trending Zaman Now

Mr.Ketupat said...

Bantu Baca Artikrl 5 Alasan Interaksi Social Menjadi Kunci Kehidupan Social

Aku kan Ikan said...

Mau tau? ini tentang komunitas untuk kegiatan sosial di masyarakat

Aku kan Ikan said...

Dia ngk baik-baik saja bro, ini yang dilakukan setelah wanita putus cinta

Savage said...

mari hidup sehat dengan cara kita menjaga kesehatan lingkungan

BOBOIBOY said...

PENGEN PERAWATAN KULIT? TAPI TAKUT PAKAI BAHAN KIMIA. YAUDAH DEH YUK PAKAI AJA SKINCARE ALAMI DENGAN perawatan wajah alami

BOBOIBOY said...

LELAH BEKERJA? BUTUH LIBURAN? YUK KETAHUI manfaat liburan

BOBOIBOY said...

SUKA MELUKIS? YUK BERKENALAN DENGAN SENI LUKIS

BOBOIBOY said...

ANAK ANDA MUDAH SAKIT? YUK AJARI OLAHRAGA DAN INI ADALAH OLAHRAGA YANG COCOK UNTUK ANAK ANDA SUKA MELUKIS? YUK BERKENALAN DENGAN OLAHRAGA ANAK

Mr.Ketupat said...

Anda sedang sakit ingin mengetahui metode pengobatan tradisional cina

Savage said...

ingin berobat tapi takut akan bahaya bahan kimia? nih alternatif alami pengobatan tradisional cina

Aku kan Ikan said...

ternyata dengan pengobatan tradisional cinaampuh melawan penyakit loh

Mr.Ketupat said...

Cara mengobati penyakit menggunakan metode pengobatan tradisional cina

Savage said...

MENJAGA KESEHATAN DENGAN MENGGUUNAKAN METODE PENGOBATAN TRADISIONAL CINA

Mr.Ketupat said...

Informasi mengenai penyembuhan penyakit menggunakan metode pengobatan tradisional cina

Aku kan Ikan said...

Jangan asal berobat, mungkin kamu perlu pengobatan tradisional cina terpercaya

Savage said...

MARI SEMBUHKAN PENYAKIT ANDA DENGAN MENGGUNAKAN METODE DARI PENGOBATAN TRADISIONAL CINA

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken daftar lantai6

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken daftar slot39

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken daftar slotboss

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken daftar slotjek

Savage said...

silahkan dicoba dijamin memuaskan daftar dynastislot

Savage said...

silahkan dicoba dijamin memuaskan daftar gacorbet88

BOBOIBOY said...

DI JAMIN MANTAP NO TIPU - TIPU daftar ahlibet88

BOBOIBOY said...

DI JAMIN PUAS BOSKU daftar balislot88

Aku kan Ikan said...

ngk perlu perlu bingung, ada ni link ahlibet88

Aku kan Ikan said...

ngk perlu perlu bingung, ada ni balislot88

Aku kan Ikan said...

ngk perlu perlu bingung, ada ni link bolagacor

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken link totoslot

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken link super88bet

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken link sultantogel88

BOBOIBOY said...

Di jamin mantap dan menarik sultantogel88

BOBOIBOY said...

Pastinya aman dan no tipu tipu super88bet

Savage said...

TERPERCAYA DAN NO TIPU TIPU BOLAGACOR

Savage said...

SILAHKAN DICOBA DIJAMIN AMAN AHLIBET88

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken dynastislot

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken gacorbet88

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken gameslot37

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken lantai6

Aku kan Ikan said...

ngk ada ragu ragu lagi sih slotboss

Aku kan Ikan said...

ngk ada ragu ragu lagi sih slot39

Aku kan Ikan said...

ngk ada ragu ragu lagi sih lantai6

BOBOIBOY said...

YUK DI COBA DULU, DIJAMIN KETAGIHAN daftar gameslot37

BOBOIBOY said...

NGAK DI COBA NANTI RUGI daftar gacorbet88

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken daftar totoslot

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken daftar super88bet

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken daftar sultantogel88

Aku kan Ikan said...

ribet banget jadi orang ngk usah drama langsung aja daftar bolagacor

Aku kan Ikan said...

ribet banget jadi orang ngk usah drama langsung aja daftar balislot88

Aku kan Ikan said...

ribet banget jadi orang ngk usah drama langsung aja daftar ahlibet88

Savage said...

PASTI DIBIKIN SENANG YUK COBA LINK SULTANTOGEL88

Savage said...

PASTI DIBIKIN SENANG YUK COBA LINK SUPER88BET

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken link bolagacor

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken link balislot88

Aku kan Ikan said...

langsung aja jangan dipersulit join link dynastislot

Aku kan Ikan said...

langsung aja jangan dipersulit join link gacorbet88

Aku kan Ikan said...

langsung aja jangan dipersulit join link gameslot37

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken alternatif lantai6

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken alternatif gameslot37

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken alternatif gacorbet88

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken alternatif dynastislot

Aku kan Ikan said...

jangan bingung ini jalan alternatif slot39

Aku kan Ikan said...

jangan bingung ini jalan alternatif slotboss

Aku kan Ikan said...

jangan bingung ini jalan alternatif lantai6

Savage said...

JANGAN SAMPAI PENASARAN, BURUAN DICOBA alternatif bolagacor

Savage said...

BAKALAN NYESEL KALAU NGGA MAU IKUTAN alternatif ahlibet88

BOBOIBOY said...

Gas kan jangan sampai lepas gameslot37

BOBOIBOY said...

Yakin ngak mau coba? gacorbet88

Aku kan Ikan said...

ngk kemana-mana si, hanya join disini balislot88

Aku kan Ikan said...

ngk kemana-mana si, hanya join disini ahlibet88

Aku kan Ikan said...

ngk kemana-mana si, hanya join disini bolagacor

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken totoslot

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken super88bet

Mr.Ketupat said...

sangat terpercaya langsung digasken sultantogel88

BOBOIBOY said...

Bentar lagi tahun baru, yuk bikin rumah jadi baru dengan warna cat rumah minimalis

BOBOIBOY said...

Perut buncit? yuk olahraga olahraga mengecilkan perut

BOBOIBOY said...

yuk belajar aliran lukisan

BOBOIBOY said...

Yuk pelajari lebih dalam tentang kebiasaan kita Keramas

BOBOIBOY said...

bingung liburan disitu - situ aja? Wisata luar negeri

BOBOIBOY said...

bibir kering yuk kita bikin bibir jadi lembab di Pelembab bibir

Aku kan Ikan said...

mau deketin cewek? tapi cuek? cara meluluhkan cewek cuek

Aku kan Ikan said...

doi suka warna kuning? ini dia arti dari warna kuning

Aku kan Ikan said...

Pusing selalu minum Obat Paracetamol?

Aku kan Ikan said...

Ini dia pengertian tentang sosiologi, sosiologi adalah

Aku kan Ikan said...

Mungkin yang lahir 90an merindukan ini film Xmen ini urutan film Xmen, ada yang ingat?

Aku kan Ikan said...

sejarah dan rahasia tentang gamelan jawa nih

Mr.Ketupat said...

hidup harus saling komunikasi dan juga kehidupan sosial

Mr.Ketupat said...

kemampuan memang harus diasah maupun kreativitas

Mr.Ketupat said...

main ps4 ada game elden ring

Mr.Ketupat said...

jauh disana ada kata kata anak rantau

Mr.Ketupat said...

informasi mengenai travel jakarta bandung

Mr.Ketupat said...

mau tau tentang manfaat teh hijau

Aku kan Ikan said...

mau deketin cewek? tapi cuek? fakta psikologis wanita

Aku kan Ikan said...

Kalo belum tau ini tentang black panther t'challa

Aku kan Ikan said...

Ini nih Penjelasan Tentang Art of the zoo

Aku kan Ikan said...

Ini dia pengertian tentang Gototng Royong, gotong royong adalah

Aku kan Ikan said...

bahaya pergaulan bebas, akibat dari seks bebas

Aku kan Ikan said...

pacar kamu suka banget Warna merah? ini dia arti dari warna merah

Mr.Ketupat said...

ide menarik mengenai kerajinan

Mr.Ketupat said...

main ps4 ada game sekiro

Mr.Ketupat said...

jauh disana ada anak rantau

Mr.Ketupat said...

informasi mengenai travel terdekat

Mr.Ketupat said...

mau tau tentang es teh indonesia

Aku kan Ikan said...

Punya Hewan Peliharaan? Pentingnya menjaga Kesehatan Hewan Peliharaan

Aku kan Ikan said...

Ini nih Beberapa Kerajinan Tangan Untuk anak

Aku kan Ikan said...

ada yang Viral Anak Bermata Biru, Fakta Tentang Warna Mata

Aku kan Ikan said...

Suka Barcelona? Ini dia Fakta Tentang Ibrahim Affelay

Savage said...

suka sakit punggung? cari tau penyebab sakit punggung

Savage said...

Ingin menjadi pemain sepak bola ini dia teknik dasar sepak bola

Savage said...

ingin menjaga kesehatan harus tau dulu pola makan sehat

Savage said...

rekomendasi jika ingin memelihara anjing cihuahua

Aku kan Ikan said...

kemarin tentang anti sosial nah Kalau Asosial Adalah

Aku kan Ikan said...

Film terfavorite pada jamannya ini dia Tentang Fantastic Four

BOBOIBOY said...

WAH TERNYATA SPERMA PRIA BERMANFAAT UNTUK KECANTIKAN JUGA LOH MANFAAT SPERMA PRIA UNTUK KECANTIKAN

BOBOIBOY said...

PENGEN JALAN - JALAN, TAPI UANG PAS - PASAN? TIPS JALAN - JALAN HEMAT

BOBOIBOY said...

RAMBUT KAMU BERKUTU? YUK BASMI DENGAN CARA MENGHILANGKAN KUTU RAMBUT

BOBOIBOY said...

WAH TERNYATA LUKISAN REALISME BAGUS BANGET YAH LUKISAN REALISME

BOBOIBOY said...

BINGUNG MAU PASANG UBIN LANTAI WARNA APA? WARNA UBIN LANTAI YANG BAGUS

BOBOIBOY said...

TUBUH NGAK IDEAL? YUK TINGKATKAN DENGAN OLAHRAGA UNTUK MENINGKATKAN TUBUH

Mr.Ketupat said...

kembangkan ide dengan membuatkerajinan bahan lunak

Mr.Ketupat said...

main ps4 ada game mortalkombat 11

Mr.Ketupat said...

mau tau tentang teh hijau

Savage said...

SALAH TIDUR? NIH POSISI TIDUR BIAR TIDAK SAKIT PINGGANG
INI DIA INDUK ORGANISASI INTERNASIONAL SEPAK BOLA
PUNYA PELIHARAAN KUCING DIRUMAH? INI ADA MANFAAT CATNIP UNTUK KUCING
DI MASA PUBERTAS JUGA PENTING UNTUK MENJAGA KESEHATAN TUBUH
JIKA ANDA MENCARI ANJING SETIA, CANTIK, DAN JUGA PENYAYANG INI DIA SI ANJING HUSKY
SUKA IKAN HIAS? IKAN INI COCOK UNTUK ANDA IKAN CUPANG

Aku kan Ikan said...

sebelum gambar pemandangan, ini dia tentang seni alam

Aku kan Ikan said...

Ini dia Fakta Tentang Film Venom

Aku kan Ikan said...

Bingung? Apa itu Asuransi Kesehatan?

Aku kan Ikan said...

Mau Ganti Iphone ini dia Tentang Iphone 14 Pro Max

Aku kan Ikan said...

Cari Jodoh? Ini dia Ciri-ciri Wanita Dewasa

Aku kan Ikan said...

Apasih Arti dari Musyawarah? Musyawarah adalah

BOBOIBOY said...

TERNYATA PARE YANG PAHI JUGA BERMANFAAT UNTUK KECANTIKAN LOH MANFAAT PARE UNTUK KECANTIKAN

BOBOIBOY said...

APA SIH KEUNTUNGAN HIDUP DITEMPAT WISATA? EKONOMI KREATIF

BOBOIBOY said...

RAMBUT LAMA PERTUMBUHAN NYA? PENGEN CEPAT PANJANG? CARA MENUMBUHKAN RAMBUT CEPAT

BOBOIBOY said...

PENASARAN NGAK SIH SENI LUKIS ITU UNSURNYA APA AJA? UNSUR DALAM SENI LUKIS

BOBOIBOY said...

PENGEN CAT RUMAH TERLIHAT BAGUS? WARNA CAT LUAR RUANGAN YANG BAGUS

Savage said...

TUBUH BAGIAN BELAKANG ANDA BERMASALAH? INI DIA OBAT SAKIT PINGGANG BELAKANG

Savage said...

SUKA SEPAK BOLA? HARUS TAU LAMA PERMAINAN SEPAK BOLA ADALAH

Savage said...

INGIN MEMELIHARA KUCING YANG CANTIK DAN BERBULU HALUS? INI DIA SI KUCING ANGGORA

Savage said...

SUKA IKAN HIAS? INI ADA FAKTA MENARIK TENTANG IKAN KOI

Savage said...

SUKA MELAKUKAN SENAM? INI DIA MANFAAT SENAM IRAMA BAGI KESEHATAN TUBUH

Savage said...

PECINTA ANJING HARUS TAU TENTANG FAKTA ANJING HUSKY

Aku kan Ikan said...

Belum tau? ini dia tentang Pengertian seni menurut para ahli

Aku kan Ikan said...

Ini dia Fakta Tentang Wolverine

Aku kan Ikan said...

Apasih Arti dari Ambivert? Ambivert adalah

Aku kan Ikan said...

Bingung? ini dia tentang menjaga kesehatan lingkungan

Aku kan Ikan said...

ini dia 10 rekomendasi warna lensa

Aku kan Ikan said...

mata duitan? jangan salah ini dia peran penting wanita dengan keuangan

BOBOIBOY said...

PENGEN PUNYA BIBIR YANG TIPIS? CARA MENIPISKAN BIBIR

BOBOIBOY said...

SERING KE PANTAI? NAH INI DIA BARANG YANG NGK BOLEH DI LUPAIN KETIKA KE PANTAI BARANG YANG WAJIB DIBAWA KE PANTAI

BOBOIBOY said...

PENGEN PUNYA RAMBUT LURUS, TAPI RAMBUT NYA NGEMBANG CARA MELURUSKAN RAMBUT MENGEMBANG

BOBOIBOY said...

YANG HARUS DIKETAHUI DALAM MELUKIS LUKISAN BERDASARKAN TEKNIK DAN BAHAN

BOBOIBOY said...

BINGUNG MAU CAT KAMAR DENGAN WARNA APA? WARNA CAT KAMAR TIDUR YANG MENENANGKAN

BOBOIBOY said...

ALASAN MENGAPA HARUS PENDINGINAN SEELAH OLAHRAGA PENDINGINAN SETELAH OLAHRAGA

Mr.Ketupat said...

main ps4 ada game days gone

Mr.Ketupat said...

informasi mengenai jasa travel

Savage said...

INI DIA PENYEBAB GEJALA DAN PENGOBATAN SAKIT PUNGGUNG

Savage said...

PEMAIN PENGGEMAR ATAU PENONTON SEPAK BOLA MARI UNTUK MENGENAL LAPANGAN SEPAK BOLA

Savage said...

INGIN MENCARI HEWAN PELIHARAAN SEMPURNA? INI PILIHAN YANG TEPAT ADALAH KUCING ANGGORA

«Oldest ‹Older   1 – 200 of 988   Newer› Newest»